In my final word on the subject for the foreseeable future, today is the actual 25th anniversary of the start of the 1984-5 miners’ strike. The thousands of words published in the newspapers and broadcast by the BBC in recent days has been a salutary reminder of just how cluelessly idiotic most of our media really is, stuck in its cosy middle class bubble down south, claiming that this strike was about one Loony Leftist’s colossal ego.
One of the mightiest books to deal with the strike was Seumas Milne’s The Enemy Within – still in print and still essential reading. It is therefore fitting that he has in today’s Guardian ripped into the media’s representation of this anniversary with the most clear-minded exposition of the true heart of the conflict.
A generation later… debates about the strike can seem arcane. But its outcome could not matter more for the country we have inherited. It’s not just the wreckage of mining communities, but the entire political and economic direction has been shaped by the fallout from that convulsive dispute. The enfeeblement of unions, the explosion of inequality, social atomisation, the collapse of confidence in a political alternative and Britain’s harsh brand of neoliberalism all flow from its aftermath. Success for the miners would, by contrast, have at least seriously weakened Thatcher, reined in the government’s worst excesses and halted Labour’s headlong rush for the third way…
The strike was a fight for jobs, but it was also a challenge to the market-driven restructuring of economic and social life already under way. It raised the alternative of a different Britain from the greed and individualism of the Thatcher years, rooted in solidarity and collective action. As the neoliberal order that Thatcher helped to build crumbles before us, that is a message that speaks to our times.
The miners had already witnessed their industry shrink by a quarter in the decade to March 1984; they knew what would happen to their communities – and their children’s futures – if the further proposed contraction of the industry was not managed properly.
The overwhelming majority of those who stayed loyal to the cause and, crucially, their families knew what was at stake. The support shown by the wives and children of those who stayed out for the duration is the most inspiring – and ultimately heartbreaking – display of solidarity I’ve ever witnessed. Tens of thousands of men, women and children literally froze and starved to try to save their societies.
I live, and still struggle to deal, with the knowledge that the area in which I was born and raised was one of the areas that most readily broke the strike; the knowledge that we would not now be Posh Boy Dave’s “broken society” or stuck in the middle of the Clusterfuck had it not been for the crushing of the miners and – crucially – the manner in which their backs were broken.
The BBC and the government might be keen to show off how some former pits have now been turned into call centres and “energy parks” but there are many more former pit villages that remain half-derelict and half-deserted, where all that remains are large pockets of poverty, drug addiction and lawlessness.
Despite it being That Bloody Woman’s most misrepresented utterance, there really is now “no such thing as society“. And that is largely because of the way in which free market capitalism assumed totemic importance above all else in the years after the state, the law and the media conspired to destroy an industry.
The week after the return to work the ever charming and self-effacing Chairman of the National Coal Board, Ian MacGregor, chuckled to a national newspaper reporter that the strikers would have to pay for their actions, “And, boy, will we make them pay.”
It wasn’t only the strikers who paid: it was all of us. We’ve been paying for a generation. And thanks to the Clusterfuck, we’re going to be paying for at least another generation to come.
Well said, sir. Time and time again Scargill has been proved right, right, right. He has been exonerated more than any man. Yet he now remains a relic of a misrepresented past. He was not a saint and may not even have been a great man. He was ultimately a failure. But what he had going for him which all the quisling fucks up and down the country who misremember and misreport what happened will never have, is that he stuck up for what he thought was right…and it WAS right.